| Feb 21, 2026 | Costello | 1–0 | Cooper | Round 2: Costello, Colin A - Cooper, Malcolm H | Slav Defense: Quiet Variation, Schallopp Defense | |
| Feb 20, 2026 | Pasqualetto | 1–0 | Costello | Round 1: Pasqualetto, Lorenzo - Costello, Colin A | Italian Game: Classical Variation, Giuoco Pianissimo | |
| May 28, 2025 | Vavulin | 1–0 | Costello | Round 1: Vavulin, Maxim - Costello, Colin A | Nimzo-Larsen Attack: Modern Variation | |
| Feb 23, 2025 | Costello | ½–½ | Tarrant-Edwards | Round 5: Costello, Colin A - Tarrant-Edwards, Philip | Queen's Gambit Declined: Vienna Variation, Quiet Variation | |
| Feb 23, 2025 | Catabay | ½–½ | Costello | Round 4: Catabay, Mae Katelyn Rose - Costello, Colin A | Queen's Pawn Game: Torre Attack | |
| Feb 22, 2025 | Costello | ½–½ | Catabay | Round 3: Costello, Colin A - Catabay, Rezin C | English Opening: King's English Variation, Four Knights Variation, Fianchetto Line | |
| Feb 22, 2025 | Tso | ½–½ | Costello | Round 2: Tso, Chi Wai - Costello, Colin A | Bogo-Indian Defense: Retreat Variation | |
| Feb 21, 2025 | Costello | 1–0 | Lloyd | Round 1: Costello, Colin A - Lloyd, Joel | Semi-Slav Defense: Normal Variation | |
| Feb 21, 2025 | Saxena | ½–½ | Costello | Round 6: Saxena, Advik - Costello, Colin A | Italian Game: Classical Variation, Giuoco Pianissimo | |
| Feb 20, 2025 | Costello | 1–0 | Mottram | Round 4: Costello, Colin A - Mottram, Paul | Semi-Slav Defense | |
| Feb 20, 2025 | Costello | ½–½ | Bowley | Round 5: Costello, Colin A - Bowley, Clive | English Opening: Great Snake Variation | |
| Feb 19, 2025 | Foo | 1–0 | Costello | Round 3: Foo, Jiu Weir Brien - Costello, Colin A | Bogo-Indian Defense: Grünfeld Variation | |
| Feb 18, 2025 | Costello | 1–0 | Warner | Round 2: Costello, Colin A - Warner, Nicholas | English Opening: King's English Variation, Kramnik-Shirov Counterattack | |
| Feb 18, 2025 | Sainbayar | 0–1 | Costello | Round 1: Sainbayar, Anuurai - Costello, Colin A | Polish Opening | |
| Oct 12, 2024 | Boesel | 1–0 | Costello | Round 1: Boesel, Alexander - Costello, Colin A | Italian Game: Giuoco Pianissimo, Normal | |
| Nov 17, 2024 | Costello | 0–1 | Shevchenko | Round 5: Costello, Colin A - Shevchenko, Igor | French Defense: Steiner Variation | |
| Nov 17, 2024 | Heirich | ½–½ | Costello | Round 4: Heirich, Andreas - Costello, Colin A | Nimzo-Indian Defense | |
| Nov 16, 2024 | Costello | ½–½ | Beckmann | Round 3: Costello, Colin A - Beckmann, Jonathan | English Opening: King's English Variation, Four Knights Variation, Flexible Line | |
| Nov 16, 2024 | Stoeber | 1–0 | Costello | Round 2: Stoeber, Alexander - Costello, Colin A | Italian Game: Scotch Gambit, Janowski Defense | |
| Nov 15, 2024 | Costello | 0–1 | Laube | Round 1: Costello, Colin A - Laube, Reiner | English Opening: Anglo-Dutch Defense | |
| Aug 21, 2022 | Chandler | ½–½ | Costello | Chessable British Chess Championships: Seniors 65+ | Four Knights Game: Scotch Variation Accepted | |
| Aug 19, 2022 | Barton | 0–1 | Costello | Chessable British Chess Championships: Seniors 65+ | Queen's Pawn Game: Colle System | |
| Aug 18, 2022 | Costello | 1–0 | Jerome | Chessable British Chess Championships: Seniors 65+ | English Opening: Myers Defense | |
| Aug 17, 2022 | Bray | ½–½ | Costello | Chessable British Chess Championships: Seniors 65+ | Bogo-Indian Defense: Retreat Variation | |
| Aug 16, 2022 | Hutchinson | ½–½ | Costello | Chessable British Chess Championships: Seniors 65+ | Queen's Pawn Game: Accelerated London System | |
| Aug 15, 2022 | Costello | ½–½ | James | Chessable British Chess Championships: Seniors 65+ | English Opening: Carls-Bremen System | |
| — | Costello | 0–1 | Footner | Chessable British Chess Championships: Seniors 65+ | English Opening: King's English Variation, Taimanov Variation | |
| — | Costello | 1–0 | Clancy | Round 2: Costello, Colin A - Clancy, Martin J | English Opening: Anglo-Indian Defense, Queen's Knight Variation | |
| — | Costello | ½–½ | Clark | Round 4: Costello, Colin A - Clark, Robert G | English Opening: King's English Variation, Four Knights Variation, Fianchetto Line, with Nb6 | |
| — | Costello | 1–0 | De Coverly | Round 6: Costello, Colin A - De Coverly, Roger D | English Opening: Anglo-Indian Defense, Queen's Knight Variation | |
| — | Costello | 0–1 | Ichim | Round 2: Costello, Colin A - Ichim, Grieg | English Opening: Symmetrical Variation, Anti-Benoni Variation, Spielmann Defense | |
| — | Costello | 0–1 | Jamie Barnes | Round 4: Costello, Colin A - Jamie Barnes | English Opening: Symmetrical Variation, Four Knights Variation | |
| — | James | 1–0 | Costello | Round 1: James, Geoffrey H - Costello, Colin A | Ruy Lopez: Morphy Defense, Anderssen Variation | |
| — | Moore | ½–½ | Costello | Round 3: Moore, Geoffrey R - Costello, Colin A | King's Indian Attack | |
| — | Habershon | ½–½ | Costello | Round 5: Habershon, Paul F - Costello, Colin A | Scotch Game: Mieses Variation | |
| — | Pickles | 0–1 | Costello | Round 7: Pickles, Stephen - Costello, Colin A | Scotch Game: Scotch Gambit, Göring Gambit Declined | |
| — | Ashton | 1–0 | Costello | Round 1: Ashton, Adam G - Costello, Colin A | Ruy Lopez: Open, Bernstein Variation | |
| — | Collier | 0–1 | Costello | Round 3: Collier, James P - Costello, Colin A | King's Gambit Declined: Classical Variation | |
| — | Boganadham | ½–½ | Costello | Round 5: Boganadham, Ved Sudeep - Costello, Colin A | Italian Game: Scotch Gambit, Max Lange Attack Accepted | |